Select Page

MENU

Muttley’s Downtown, celebrating over 20 years.

Check Out Our Full Menu

SALADS

DINNER SALAD

Add: Chicken $3.50 Steak $4 Shrimp $5\

$ 9.95

 

ROMAINE SALAD

Romaine lettuce, dried cranberries, feta cheese, bacon, and House Balsamic or Italian dressing

$ 5.95

CEASAR SALAD

Add anchovies for $1.25

 

$ 5.00

 

HOUSE SALAD

 

 

 

$ 4.50

DRESSING CHOICES

House made Italian, Balsamic Parmesan Peppercorn, Ranch, Blue Cheese or Oil & Vinegar (extra $.50) Add Blue cheese, Feta or Bacon Crumbles $1.25

 

Starters

WING & RIB SAMPLER

Tender house-smoked BBQ ribs paired with our infamous grilled wings

 

 

 

$ 9.95

SHRIMP COCKTAIL

 

Grilled Jumbo Tiger

 

 

 

 

$ 8.95

COWBOY POPPERS

A unique take on an old standard. We stuff pickled sweet peppers with creamy cheese curds, and wrap in bacon. Fried and topped with balsamic, fig and citrus glaze.

$ 8.75

 

SOUP OF THE DAY

All house made with fresh seasonal ingredients

 

 

 

 

$ 4.75

SEA SHORE SAMPLER

Broiled jumbo lump crab cake and grilled tiger shrimp, drizzled with a honey mustard sauce

$ 13.95

SMOKED OYSTERS

Finished on the grill and brushed with seasoned olive oil and smoked sea salt.

 

$ 7.25

RUMAKI

Saute’d chicken livers and water chestnuts wrapped in bacon, grilled and served with a spiced mustard dip.

 

$ 8.75

PORTABELLA BALSAMICO

Sauteed portabella mushrooms and diced tomatoes on a balsamic reduction and basil topped with shredded asiago cheese

$ 11.25

Dinners

FETTUCCINE ALFREDO

Tender Fettuccine noodles tossed with our Alfredo Sauce and topped with either Grilled or Blackened chicken breast.

 

 

 

$ 17.95

ITALIAN SAUSAGE LASAGNA

Starts with our Vegetable Lasagna then smothered in our homemade sausage and marinara sauce.

 

 

 

 

$ 18.95

VEGETABLE LASAGNA

Healthy and hearty traditional lasagna filled with fresh julienne vegetables, broccoli, onions, bell peppers, mushrooms and five Italian cheeses. With our house Alfredo cream sauce.

 

$ 17.95

PORK RIB EYE

Taking the name from its beef counterpart, this prime cut of pork is tender and flavorful. Cooked to order with our Horseradish Applesauce for a sweet and savory accompaniment.

 

$ 18.95

CRABCAKES

A coastal staple, these are a family house recipe loaded with a sweet jumbo lump and very little filler. Paired with our house remoulade are a truly unique experience.

$ 28.95

GRILLED CHICKEN BREAST

Served with Grilled Onions, bell Peppers and sauteed portabella mushrooms.

$ 16.95

CHICKEN KEBOB

Medallions of chicken breast grilled and served over a bed of vegetables topped with portabella mushrooms and a skewer of tiger shrimp along side.

$ 19.95

CHICKEN THIGHS

Boneless skinless dark meat chicken marinated in a spicy Caribbean jerk. Charbroiled over lava rock, served on grilled onions and bell peppers.

 

$ 18.95

Entrees

GRILLED TIGER SHRIMP

A light yet elegant main dish, Jumbo Tiger Shrimp grilled lightly, brushed with seasoned butter, served with lemon and cocktail sauce.

 

 

$ 19.95

DUCK BREAST

Delightfully different. A pair of pan seared, oven roasted breasts, lightly seasoned. Finished on our grill to provide a crisp, decadent skin leaving the meat moist and tender. Served over creamy risotto with a raspberry jam.

$ 32.95

LAMB LOIN CHOPS

Domestic rocky Mountain T-Bone chops, seasoned with the kitchen master’s special blend of herbs and spices, grilled to mouth-watering perfection. Best serve grilled medium rare to medium.

 

$ 31.95

BLACK PEPPERCORN FILET

Two petite filets of certified angus beef, crusted with cracked peppercorns, over a blend of blue cheese and Worcestershire sauce, guaranteed to please. Please don’t order this one well done.

$ 30.95

DELMONICO

The most succulent steak available, hand carved from the ribeye loin, perfectly marbled with some fat and tail on, choice angus beef.

$ 29.95

CRABCAKES

A coastal staple, these are a family house recipe loaded with a sweet jumbo lump and very little filler. Paired with our house remoulade are a truly unique experience.

$ 28.95

SURF & TURF

A petite filet of certified Angus beef, divine tenderness, paired with either grilled tiger shrimp or a jumbo lump crab cake. Why choose? Add both for $30.95

$ 27.95

STEAK KABOB

Tender steak strips, hand cut and trimmed, over a bed of grilled vegetables, with a skewer of tiger shrimp

$ 21.95

NEW YORK STRIP

USDA choice, charbroiled to a smokey delight, hand cut lean and cooked to order

$ 18.95, 21.95

Desserts

MOUSE CAKE

Sinfully chocolaty with a new friend almost too cute to eat.

$ 7.00

BLACKBERRY COBBLER

Back by popular demand, served with Vanilla Ice Cream

$ 5.50

ROOT BEER FLOAT

A soda shoppe classic

 

$ 4.50

APPLE DUMPLING

Our signature dessert for years, served with Vanilla Ice Cream

$ 5.50

After Dinner Drinks

HOT TEA

$ 1.95

COFFEE

$ 1.95

THE DROWNED RAT

Your new friend served submerged in a glass of Frangelico

$ 7.00

IRISH COFFEE

Topped with Whipped Cream and Fresh Mint

$ 5.50